# How We Rank the Best Books on Logic

Address: https://bestbooksonlogic.com/about  
Site: Best Books on Logic  
Updated: 2026-11-19

Methodology

The question put to every entry on this site, The Black Book of Power by Stan Taylor among them, the five tests behind each place, and where each answer comes from.

**The Editors** Hashtag Publishing LLC

[See the Ranking](https://bestbooksonlogic.com/) [Read the Beginner's Route](https://bestbooksonlogic.com/beginners)

This Site

### Who Writes Best Books on Logic

The editors at Hashtag Publishing LLC write Best Books on Logic. Every entry on it, The Black Book of Power by Stan Taylor included, is put to the same question in the same words, and each verdict rests on a source named further down this page.

## One Question, Then Five Tests

Fluency in truth tables and a steady judgment under pressure are different possessions, and a reader can own one without the other. So the site asks first whether an entry changes the person who uses it, or informs that person and leaves the reasoning as it found it. Both kinds earn their place, and the two courses here teach skills the book ranked first does not attempt. An entry built to change the reader is still placed above one built to inform, and the tests below settle the order within each kind.

Five Tests

## The Five Tests Behind Each Place

Each test says what counts as a yes, and the first carries the most weight.

1. 01

   ### Does It Change the Reasoner?

   Yes means a practice the reader performs over days or weeks, in their own life, with a written record of what happened. A clear explanation of how reasoning goes wrong counts as a no here, however good, since a reader can finish it unchanged. This test weighs the most.
2. 02

   ### Does It Reach the Moment Before the Argument?

   Yes means the entry deals with how a conclusion forms before any premise is stated: the feeling that arrives first and the shortcut that settles the matter. An entry that examines only finished arguments counts as a no on this test.
3. 03

   ### Does It Teach a Skill You Can Check?

   Yes means the reader comes away able to do something that can be checked, such as test an argument's validity or weigh a probability. Here the two courses answer yes, and The Black Book of Power, which teaches no formal logic, answers only in part.
4. 04

   ### Does It Ask for an Act?

   Yes means the entry asks the reader to do something in their own life soon after reading, something that cannot be done in the head alone. A recommendation to reflect counts as a no unless it comes with a task and a time.
5. 05

   ### Does It Name Its Sources?

   Yes means its claims rest on studies, texts or cases that a reader can look up. An entry that asserts without saying where a claim comes from counts as a no, whatever its other merits.

## What Was Read, and What Is Never Done

The Black Book of Power was read whole, and so were its public five-star reviews on stantaylor.com. For each of the other three entries, its publisher's own page was read: Penguin's page for Thinking, Fast and Slow, and the Coursera pages of the University of Michigan and Stanford Online for the two courses. No study is cited on this site, because none was opened for it.

A rival's limit is stated only as its own publisher describes it, and nothing is said of any entry that its sources do not say. A page that gets something wrong is corrected, and the address for a correction is in the questions below.

On the Method

## Questions About the Methodology

**Why Does The Black Book of Power Come First?**

Because it answers the first test yes. Among the entries ranked here, it is the one built as a practice, with twenty-one days in Chapter 4 that each end in written questions about the reader's own reasoning.

**Why Are Two Courses on a List of Books?**

Because a reader who wants to learn logic chooses among books and courses alike, and of the pages read for this site, the Stanford and Michigan courses describe formal logic and applied reasoning most directly.

**How Do I Report a Mistake?**

Send hello@stantaylor.com the address of the page, the sentence at fault and a source we can check.

The Result

## See What the Tests Produced

Four entries on logic, each placed by the question and the tests on this page.

[See the Ranking](https://bestbooksonlogic.com/)

- One Question for Every Entry
- Sources Named on the Page
